You were about to lose me there, because I see near zero similarity between Clark and McBride as players. But the Jackson comp is a good one. I'd be pretty happy with that kind of production.
The weakness I see in your list, and there's really not much you can do about it, is that all classes are not the same. There are outliers, like 2002. 48th in that class is not the same as 48th most other years. Again, I see no way to account for it numerically, but it's there.